Odd Lots · Nov 11, 2026 · 52 min

Why crowded trades hit hedge funds hard in October and what comes next

Episode: The Perfect Storm That Clobbered Hedge Funds · With Nishant Kumar, Michael Ball

TL;DR

Hedge funds suffered a sharp October as crowded, AI-linked trades unwound together. Guests Nishant Kumar and Michael Ball explain why it happened and what they are watching now.

Key takeaways

  1. Millennium fell 2.3 percent in October, a notable move for a fund that typically annualizes near 14 percent.4:40
  2. Pivotal Path argued that large multi-strategy firms were crowding into the same names, which raises risk when those positions reverse together.13:07
  3. Goldman's work suggested the concern is crowding combined with leverage, since correlations among multi-strategy funds had stayed in a narrow band.13:57
  4. Multi-strategy firms typically cut a portfolio manager's capital sharply after losses, with closure following a further loss.16:05
  5. Kumar said one firm reportedly gained in October, but most funds lost money, and the key issue was failing to act as a hedge.6:41
  6. Ball said the October shift in the capital spending story, from growth engine to financing and free cash flow worries, drove much of the market change.33:00
  7. Ball noted that a neocloud index had fallen about 70 percent, leaving many investors with negative positioning that is costly to hold.36:53

Summary

The hosts open by describing a historic stretch for hedge funds, with October performance figures arriving in the past week and losses building since the summer as AI-adjacent stocks weakened. They frame the central question as whether multi-strategy funds, which were meant to make uncorrelated bets, had in practice been implicitly long AI all along. The episode features two Bloomberg News colleagues: Nishant Kumar, chief correspondent for hedge funds, who discusses fund performance, and Michael Ball, a macro strategist, who discusses broader markets. The conversation was recorded on November 10, after the midterm elections.

Kumar said October was an extremely busy period for coverage, but the striking feature was not simply that funds lost money. Many different strategies lost at the same time. He pointed to large multi-strategy firms, including Millennium and Exodus Point, which all lost money together. Millennium fell 2.3 percent, which he said was a notable move for a fund that typically annualizes near 14 percent. He explained that hedge funds are expected to soften losses during turmoil, so the failure was that they did not protect investors when markets fell. A few firms, including Citadel and D.E. Shaw, were reported to have done well, though the details of their positioning were not available. Kumar’s working explanation was a combination of an AI stock selloff, a surprise election in Brazil, a large bond selloff and declines in French bonds, which hit crowded trades one after another. Examples included an AI-focused fund that lost 33 percent in October but was still up for the year, an equity fund down 12 percent, and a macro fund down 6.4 percent, its worst month since it began trading.

On crowding, Kumar cited a Pivotal Path report that found the ten largest firms it studied controlled about 2.2 trillion dollars including borrowed money, with capital backing their trades of roughly 300 to 350 billion dollars. A Goldman analysis found correlations among multi-strategy funds had stayed in a narrow band for years, so the concern was crowding combined with leverage rather than correlation alone. Kumar described the multi-strategy model, in which a central risk team allocates capital to many portfolio managers. At many firms, a manager who loses 5 percent of allocated capital has it halved, and a further loss to 7.5 percent closes the position. He said this ruthless structure protects the platform from any single manager but can cause simultaneous cutbacks across the firm. One host argued that a risk manager should have spotted correlated bets. Kumar replied that correlation is hard to see until stress makes it visible.

Kumar said there were signs of recovery in early November, but many portfolio managers had been fired, poached or were sitting out non-compete periods, leaving fewer risk takers with about six weeks left in the year. On the business outlook, he said investors still want multi-strategy exposure. Millennium reportedly raised around 22 billion dollars against demand above 30 billion, while D.E. Shaw, Point72 and Citadel have returned roughly 35 to 40 billion dollars to investors who now need new homes for that capital. He said capacity is limited and that launching a new multi-strategy fund is hard because it requires hiring experienced traders, with many past attempts failing.

Ball described the Thursday after the election, when single-stock selling in growth and tech was heavy even though Wednesday had seen positions rebuilt and volatility fall. He attributed the drop to key index levels breaking, dealers’ options positioning, leveraged ETFs, volatility-control funds and systematic trend followers reducing exposure. Earlier, he said, AI momentum had faded during the summer, and in October the capital spending narrative shifted from a growth engine to concerns about financing, free cash flow, electricity constraints and local opposition. He also pointed to rising equity supply, including a planned Anthropic IPO reportedly targeting a preliminary valuation of about 1.4 trillion dollars, which is lower than expectations. A neocloud index he cited had fallen about 70 percent.

Ball also discussed oil, which had fallen on hopes of an end to the Iran conflict. He said a lower geopolitical risk premium would support the outlook for rates and inflation, although the path could be bumpy. The hosts closed by noting that multi-strategy funds’ focus on short-term returns can amplify market moves, and that for investors the key failure in October was that the hedge did not perform its purpose, not the losses alone.

Quotes

“Basically, we're multi-strats, just momentum dressed up in, I don't know, diversified sheep's clothing.”
Odd Lots · 2:35
“It was that lots of different strategies got hit at the same time.”
Odd Lots · 3:44
“Your role in a portfolio is to soften the blow from any market turmoil.”
Odd Lots · 6:10
“The theory here really is that lots of relatively small uncorrelated return streams are more robust than like one gigantic star portfolio manager putting on a bet.”
Odd Lots · 16:48

Who should listen

Investors, risk managers and finance professionals who want to understand how crowded positioning, leverage and multi-strategy fund structures can amplify market selloffs.

Listen

This summary was written with AI from the episode transcript and reviewed before publishing. Quotes are checked word for word against the transcript, and timestamps are approximate. Quotes without a named speaker are attributed to the show.