Odd Lots · Nov 9, 2026 · 53 min
How New York City collects 24 million pounds of trash a day, and why it is changing
Episode: This Is How New York City Takes Out Its Trash · With Joshua Goodman
TL;DR
Deputy Commissioner Joshua Goodman explains how the Department of Sanitation collects, processes and exports the city's daily waste, why recycling works in New York, and how on-street containers are being rolled out.
Key takeaways
- Goodman describes trash collection as the city's last free, unlimited service, with no signup, opt-in or means test.4:52
- The department handles roughly 24 million pounds of trash, recycling and compost each day, and treats the work as one that never finishes.4:04
- Planning for containers began with a volumetric analysis of 70,000 blocks, converting decades of weight data into volume estimates.12:05
- Rollout started in West Harlem, moves to downtown Brooklyn in fall 2026, and the mayor has committed to a full rollout by 2031.24:16
- Facing a five-year wait for a imported design, the department built a side-loading truck prototype itself in about 10 months.27:59
- An early estimate of 150,000 parking spaces affected has been revised to about 30,000 at full rollout, possibly fewer depending on opt-ins.31:21
- About half of line-of-duty injuries to sanitation workers are sprains and strains from throwing bags, which mechanized collection aims to reduce.32:22
- Goodman argues New York's recycling is protected by long-term contracts that guarantee materials are reused, insulating it from market shocks.15:42
Summary
Hosts Joe Weisenthal and Tracy Alloway open with a party conversation in which a man described New York trash collection as one of the last city services untouched by neoliberalism. Their guest is Joshua Goodman of the city’s Department of Sanitation, who argues that the familiar saying that there is no Republican or Democratic way to pick up garbage understates how much planning the job requires. He says the department picks up, processes and exports about 24 million pounds of trash, recycling and compostable material every day, and likens the work to an endless task that never reaches a point of being finished. He also calls trash collection the city’s last free, unlimited service, with no signup, opt-in or means test, and says that universal commitment must be kept as practices change.
Goodman traces why New York’s sidewalks are lined with bags. The 1811 street grid left the city without the rear alleyways common in other dense cities, so there was nowhere to store bins behind buildings. Metal cans were later overwhelmed, especially after the 1968 sanitation strike, and plastic bags were promoted as rodent resistant, a claim he says proved untrue. He says the city only began seriously addressing the problem in the last few years through what it calls the trash revolution, a rethinking of how roughly 8.5 million residents handle their waste. He argues that cleanliness shapes quality of life and that people notice piles of trash far more than the absence of them.
On logistics, Goodman says collection trucks typically run between midnight and 8:30 in the morning and carry 12 to 13 tons each before heading to a network of transfer stations. After the Staten Island landfill closed, the city built five transfer stations, where waste is loaded into containers for barges and rail to destinations outside the city. He describes recycling as protected by long-term contracts guaranteeing reuse, and says New York was insulated from the 2017 and 2018 collapse of recycling markets because it had avoided combining paper with other recyclables. Compost is turned for three or four months on Staten Island and given away to residents, while food waste also goes to digesters that produce fertilizer and biogas.
The central change now is on-street containerization. The department analyzed 70,000 blocks, converting decades of weight data into volume, and measured piles of trash and streetscapes on site. It rejected the shared open bins common in Europe, partly out of concern that businesses might misuse free space, and designed a tiered system. Buildings with one to nine units use wheeled bins, mid-sized buildings choose between options, and buildings with 31 or more units get their own larger on-street containers. The program began in West Harlem in June 2025, moves to downtown Brooklyn in fall 2026, and the mayor has committed to funding a full rollout by the end of 2031. To move quickly, the department worked with vendors to produce a side-loading truck prototype in about 10 months, combining a European body with a Mack chassis. An earlier estimate that the program could take up to 150,000 parking spaces has been revised to about 30,000 at full rollout, possibly fewer depending on opt-ins.
Goodman also covers workers and litter. Each truck carries two workers, and he says about half of line-of-duty injuries are sprains and strains from throwing bags, so mechanized collection could ease strain on backs and knees. He reports more needle-stick injuries, which he assumes stem from discarded medication supplies bought online. Bulky items will still be collected by traditional trucks, and he notes Barcelona had to adjust after converting its fleet too heavily. On litter, he describes a 2018 pilot that removed every litter basket in one district, and says the department now focuses on built-environment design, drawing on urban planner Oscar Newman’s ideas about defensible space.
The hosts note that charging by weight is not used, a choice that effectively spreads costs across residents, and they see bin placement as the hardest remaining question. Goodman argues that claims of New York exceptionalism around trash are a nostalgic reflex, since the city’s waste stream has changed many times before.
Quotes
“Just as Sisyphus faced the boulder again each day, we pick up 24 million pounds today.”
“There will never be a time when DSNY says, great news, everyone. We got it all.”
“They rarely, if ever, notice the absence of piles of trash.”
“We hate the trash. The trash is our enemy, as fascinating as it is to study.”
Who should listen
Listeners interested in city infrastructure, urban logistics or municipal policy, especially anyone curious how a dense city handles everyday waste.
Listen
This summary was written with AI from the episode transcript and reviewed before publishing. Quotes are checked word for word against the transcript, and timestamps are approximate. Quotes without a named speaker are attributed to the show.