Odd Lots · Nov 5, 2026 · 32 min
James Bosworth on Lula's Brazil win, Venezuela's transition and the orange wave
Episode: James Bosworth on What Comes After Lula's Stunning Win · With James Bosworth
TL;DR
Bosworth explains how Lula overcame a first-round deficit to beat Flavio Bolsonaro, whether the Trump-aligned orange wave is cresting, and what a Venezuelan election could look like.
Key takeaways
- Bosworth says the first round acted as a referendum on Lula, and Flavio's first-place finish brought scrutiny that let Lula catch up.5:31
- Lula's campaign used short, shareable debate clips and a large WhatsApp network that Bosworth credits with helping drive voters to the polls.6:34
- Bosworth had given Bolsonaro about a 64 percent chance, and he concedes that prediction markets, at around 80 percent, were overconfident.7:36
- Turnout shifted by under 2 percent between rounds, which Bosworth says was enough to decide an election won by about 4 million votes.9:05
- Evangelical voters largely backed Bolsonaro and Catholic voters largely backed Lula, a divide that Bosworth links to church recruiting and social policy.13:02
- Bosworth expects every Latin American leader to keep having to respond to Trump on issues such as tariffs until he leaves office in January 2029.15:19
- Bosworth says a Venezuelan election would need roughly six to nine months of preparation, making a vote this year unlikely.17:50
- Bosworth says large oil companies want rule-of-law guarantees before committing to Venezuela, so only smaller, short-term firms have entered so far.22:48
Summary
The episode opens with the hosts noting that Lula da Silva’s upset win in Brazil and the return of Venezuelan opposition leader Maria Corina Machado make this a good moment to revisit Latin American politics with James Bosworth, a non-resident fellow at the Stimson Center and author of the Latin America Risk Report. Bosworth argues that Flavio Bolsonaro was a weak candidate. He points to the legal and political baggage tied to the Bolsonaro name, including his father’s conviction over a coup attempt, and to Flavio’s own problems, such as money laundering accusations from his time as a congressman, a link to a major banking scandal, and a magazine report tying him to lobbyists. Bosworth’s central explanation is that the first round was a referendum on the incumbent Lula, not on Flavio. Coming first in that round put Flavio under intense scrutiny and let Lula catch up. Bosworth also credits Lula’s campaign, which brought in younger staff, built a large WhatsApp network that helped drive voters to the polls, and produced short debate clips that traveled well on social media.
On forecasting, Bosworth says he had Bolsonaro winning with about a 64 percent chance the night before the vote, while prediction markets were around 80 percent and at one point near 87 percent. He concedes the markets were overconfident. He says the shift between rounds was small, with turnout rising by less than 2 percent and some blank or invalidated first-round ballots moving to Lula, but in a race decided by about 4 million votes that was enough to matter. He also describes a public spat between Flavio and his stepmother, Michelle Bolsonaro, which he says hurt Flavio among women voters. On the Bolsonaro movement, he says the fracturing is smaller than four years ago, when centrist parties backed Lula after the coup attempt, but there is now a recognition that the Bolsonaro name may not be the right choice for 2030. He suggests a different right-wing candidate, such as Tarcisio de Freitas, would likely have beaten Lula.
Bosworth then discusses the growth of evangelical Christianity in Brazil, which he says now roughly matches the Catholic share of the population. Polls showed evangelicals largely backing Bolsonaro and Catholics largely backing Lula. He links the trend partly to evangelical churches actively recruiting and partly to a conservative Catholic position on social policy that contrasts with Lula’s more liberal coalition. Turning to the orange wave, Bosworth argues the recent pro-Trump wins were more an anti-incumbent pendulum than a clear rightward shift. He expects Trump’s pressure to shape Latin American leaders through January 2029, since every government, left or right, has to respond to him on issues such as tariffs. He says the Iran war has not directly affected how regional leaders deal with Trump, but it has raised fuel and inflation costs, which hurts incumbents. He has seen no polling evidence that being friendly with Trump has been penalized, although Brazil’s commodity exports may have cushioned it.
On Venezuela, Bosworth says a new election would take six to nine months of preparation, and he expects the realistic timing to be mid to late next year. He describes a Rubio plan in which acting president Delcy Rodriguez declares a vacancy, a new electoral board is named, and elections follow about six months later, with Rodriguez likely preferring a later date. He says Lula has called for new elections and may want to reassert Brazil’s influence in South America, though the Venezuelan opposition distrusts him. Bosworth notes that oil majors are watching Venezuela but are waiting for rule-of-law guarantees, so far only smaller firms have moved in alongside Chevron. He describes the reported U.S. talks on a military presence as a status of forces agreement rather than a permanent base. He says Machado would very likely win a free election, but she would need to win the loyalty of the armed forces, rebuild a collapsed economy, and restore pluralism and checks and balances. The hosts also briefly discuss U.S. midterms, where Bosworth expects Democrats to take the House but sees the Senate as close to a coin flip, and upcoming races in Ecuador, Guatemala and Argentina, which he says will shape the next regional pendulum swing. One host doubts that being seen as too close to Trump is electorally costless.
Quotes
“In some ways, coming in first place in the first round was the worst thing that could happen to Flavio Bolsonaro…”
“Lula, who had never really understood social media, even though Brazil is the most online country potentially in the entire world…”
“Better than 90 percent, assuming everything was free and fair, Maria Karina Machado wins.”
“You're not going to rebuild with a company that has never done serious oil drilling elsewhere in the world.”
Who should listen
Listeners following Latin American politics or U.S. foreign policy who want a concise, expert read on Brazil's election and the prospects for Venezuela's transition.
Listen
This summary was written with AI from the episode transcript and reviewed before publishing. Quotes are checked word for word against the transcript, and timestamps are approximate. Quotes without a named speaker are attributed to the show.